What We're Seeing in 2027: Who's Buying Private Health Insurance
Anonymized patterns from one independent broker's active clients and lead records, heading into the 2027 open enrollment. There are no names or premiums here, just what the numbers in my book have been telling me.
Who is buying private health insurance heading into 2027?
In my book, it's mostly working-age people and families who buy their own coverage: about 6 in 10 of my active clients are 26 to 44, and the 35–44 group tends to stay with me the longest. The top reasons people book a call are losing job-based coverage (about 44% of bookings), going self-employed or 1099 (about 25%), and a big premium jump at renewal (about 19%). Bigger households and families earning above the subsidy line have been the most likely to become clients. These are observations from the book of Ryan Michalek at Michalek Health Solutions, an independent broker in Tampa, Florida licensed in 31 states, as of October 2026, from one brokerage's data, not a survey of the whole market.
Most of what gets written about health insurance comes from the top down: national enrollment reports, rate filings, policy analysis. That's useful, but it doesn't tell you who actually picks up the phone. This page is the bottom-up view. Every number below comes from my own active client roster and lead records as of October 2026, rounded and stripped of anything personal. It's one broker's book, shaped by who finds me (mostly self-employed people and families buying their own coverage), so read it as a field report, not a census.
1. Most of my clients are 26 to 44
About 6 in 10 of my active clients are between 26 and 44. That's the stretch of life when people age off a parent's plan, leave a salaried job to go out on their own, get married, and start having kids, and each one is a moment when job-based coverage stops being a given. Within that group, the 35–44 crowd tends to stay with me the longest. My read: by then people have usually settled into their work and their family, so once the coverage fits, they keep it.
2. Bigger households are more likely to become clients
In my lead data, the share of inquiries that turn into a client rises with household size, from roughly 2.6% for a one-person household, climbing to about 6.6% for households of four or more. I think a few things drive that: a family has more riding on the decision, it's often comparing several people's doctors and needs at once, and it tends to get more out of having one person sort it all out. A single, healthy person shopping on price alone is more likely to browse and go it alone. If you're buying for a household, my family health insurance guide covers how those decisions usually come together.
3. Families above the subsidy line were the most likely to become clients
Households earning above the marketplace subsidy line were the income group most likely to become clients in my data. That lines up with how the math works: when there's no premium tax credit to lean on, the marketplace stops being the automatic answer, and setting a full-price ACA plan side by side with private, off-exchange coverage is worth the time. Those are the families who most often want a second set of eyes. If you're not sure which side of the line you're on, the ACA subsidy cliff guide explains how it works.
4. Why people book: three triggers cover most calls
When someone books a call with me, they tell me what's going on. Across those bookings, three reasons stand out:
- Losing job-based coverage, about 44% of bookings. A layoff, a resignation, a retirement before 65, or an employer dropping its plan. Often it comes with a deadline. See just lost your health insurance?
- Going self-employed or 1099, about 25%. New freelancers, contractors, and business owners who now have to buy their own plan for the first time. See self-employed & 1099 coverage
- Premium jump at renewal, about 19%. People whose renewal notice jumped enough that they started shopping. See premium went up?
The rest is a mix: moving states, a new baby, a divorce, turning 26. The pattern I notice most is that people rarely shop for health insurance on a quiet Tuesday. Something changes, and the clock starts.
5. Split plans are common when one spouse is self-employed
A pattern I see often: one spouse is self-employed and the other has a W-2 job with a workplace plan. Sometimes the whole family goes on the employer plan. Just as often, the family ends up split, with part of the household on the job-based plan and part on an individual plan, because adding a spouse or kids to the workplace plan can cost more than covering them separately. Whether a split makes sense depends on the employer plan's family cost, the networks, and each person's health, so it's worth running both ways. My self-employed family health insurance guide walks through the setup.
6. How my book lines up with the national numbers
A single book can mislead you if you read it alone, so I check it against the national picture. Three numbers from KFF's October 30, 2026 review of the 2027 open enrollment frame what I'm hearing on the phone, checked November 8, 2026:
- The average benchmark silver premium is up about 13% for 2027, after a 26% jump for 2026. Stack the two years together and it's roughly 42% since 2025. That's the renewal-shock trigger above, in national form.
- Insurers are reshuffling: KFF counted 11 insurer exits and 7 entries for 2027 as of late October. When a company leaves, its members don't get to stay put, so a forced switch lands on top of a price increase. My insurer-leaving checklist walks through what to do first.
- The individual market is shrinking: KFF puts it at about 20.5 million people by June 2026, down from 25.2 million, and the Congressional Budget Office projects about 13.1 million in 2027. Fewer people buying their own plans doesn't mean fewer people need coverage. In my experience, a lot of them are the ones who earn too much for help and stopped assuming the marketplace was the only door.
When people book, the words they use are plain. They say their plan got too expensive, or that they need help because they're above the subsidy line, or that they want coverage outside the ACA after seeing their new rate. Those three phrasings, in one form or another, show up in my call notes more than anything else this fall, and they match the national numbers above. If any of them sounds like you, the coverage cost estimator is a fair first step before we talk.
Source: KFF, 9 things to watch for the 2027 ACA open enrollment period, October 30, 2026 (benchmark premium change, insurer exits and entries as of October 29, 2026, individual-market enrollment and the CBO projection). Call-note phrasings are paraphrased from my own lead log, with no names.
What I expect this open enrollment
Full-price renewals above the subsidy line. The enhanced marketplace subsidies that had temporarily softened the subsidy cliff expired at the end of 2025 and have not been extended for 2027. Households above the line face renewals with no premium tax credit to cushion them, on top of another year of rising marketplace rates. Based on who already calls me, that's the biggest wave I expect this open enrollment, which runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027 in states that use HealthCare.gov.
Work-visa holders losing premium tax credits. According to CMS guidance released in October 2026, starting with 2027 plans, premium tax credits and income-based cost-sharing help are limited to U.S. citizens, U.S. nationals, and a defined group of "eligible noncitizens": lawful permanent residents (green card holders), Cuban and Haitian entrants, and people living here under a Compact of Free Association. Other lawfully present people, including many on work visas, can generally still enroll in a marketplace plan, but at full price. If that's you, it's worth comparing the full-price marketplace plan against private options now rather than at renewal. Your exact eligibility is the Marketplace's determination, and immigration-status questions belong with an immigration attorney; my new to the USA guide covers the coverage side.
None of this predicts what any one person's plan will do, and Congress could still act. It's simply where my own data points as the window opens.
How I put this together
The figures on this page come from Michalek Health Solutions' own records as of October 2026: my active client roster (for ages and how long people stay), my lead records (for how often inquiries became clients, by household size and income band), and the reasons people give when they book a call. Percentages are rounded. Nothing here identifies a client, and I don't publish premiums or individual results. Because it's a single independent brokerage that focuses on the self-employed and families, my book skews toward those groups. That's a limitation, and it's also the point: it shows who is actually reaching out to a broker like me. I plan to refresh it as the data changes. If you reference it, please cite "Michalek Health Solutions, What We're Seeing in 2027, October 2026."
For the individual stories behind these numbers, one situation at a time, see my field notes.
Sources for the policy changes: CMS — noncitizen eligibility for APTC and CSRs, plan year 2027 · HealthCare.gov — saving on marketplace costs · KFF — Affordable Care Act analysis. Book and lead figures are Michalek Health Solutions' own. Educational and general; not tax, legal, or immigration advice.
Start where you fit: Self-employed & 1099 coverage · Family health insurance · Open enrollment 2027 · Run the free estimator
What my 2027 data says, answered straight.
Who is buying private health insurance in 2027?
In my book, mostly working-age people and families who buy their own coverage. About 6 in 10 of my active clients are 26 to 44, and the 35 to 44 group tends to stay the longest. Bigger households and families earning above the subsidy line have been the most likely to become clients. These are observations from one independent brokerage's data as of October 2026, not a survey of the whole market.
Why do people shop for private health insurance?
Usually because something changed. In my bookings, the top reasons are losing job-based coverage (about 44%), going self-employed or 1099 (about 25%), and a big premium jump at renewal (about 19%). The rest is a mix of moves, new babies, divorce, and turning 26.
Do work-visa holders get ACA subsidies in 2027?
According to CMS guidance released in October 2026, starting with 2027 plans, premium tax credits are limited to U.S. citizens, U.S. nationals, and certain eligible noncitizens: green card holders, Cuban and Haitian entrants, and people living here under a Compact of Free Association. Other lawfully present people, including many on work visas, can generally still enroll in a marketplace plan but at full price. The Marketplace makes the final eligibility call, so confirm your own status there.
Can spouses be on different health plans?
Yes, and it's common in my book when one spouse is self-employed and the other has a W-2 job with a workplace plan. Part of the family may stay on the employer plan while the rest goes on an individual plan, because adding family members at work can cost more than covering them separately. Whether a split makes sense depends on the employer plan's family cost, the networks, and each person's health, so it's worth comparing both ways.
In their words
“I’ve had nothing but a positive experience working with Ryan. I sense that he really knows his stuff and cares about finding the adequate plans for his clients. Most brokerages sell you a policy and leave you to fend for yourself, with Ryan that’s not the case. Overall tremendous service and support. Highly recommended”
— Brian S.
See yourself in these numbers? Let's look at your situation.
Whether you just lost a job plan, went out on your own, or opened a renewal you didn't expect, I'll compare your real options side by side and tell you straight which one fits. What day this week works for a quick call?